What comes first?

April kicks off two separate short story writing competitions for me. So, I started going through my folder of ideas and characters and it struck me the varied ways stories come.

It made me wonder. Which comes first for you, as an author?

The story idea?

Or the Characters?

For me, it has come both ways. For my short story, “Maggie,” the characters came first, then the story idea followed.

For “Obsessed,” the story idea came first and the characters followed.

Is there any right or wrong way? Absolutely NOT! It is exactly the same concept with songwriting. Sometimes the melody comes first and the lyrics follow. Other times, the lyrics come and the melody follows. But, on rare occasions, both the melody and lyrics come together hand-in-hand.

That’s when there is magic!

And when the magic happens, the readers feel it. Or, in the case of music, the listeners.

In the first Creative Writing class I ever took, the professor asked the question, “What does every human have in common?”

Of course, the answers were that we breathe air, we drink water, we have to eat and require sleep. He agreed with all those answers, but he said the one characteristic that every human being possesses is the innate desire to feel something. The answers to “feel what?” are as varied as there are individuals. But, the desire to feel is present in everyone in some form or fashion.

As writers, it is our job to make sure that happens with our stories.

But, I’m curious. Which comes first for you? The story idea? Or the characters? Or, like with me, does it vary?

  • Comment (21)
  • D.L Finn, Author says:

    Great discussion Jan. I would have to say both but I lean towards the idea over characters. Good point we need to feel too. Best of luck on both of your writing projects!

  • Gwen Plano says:

    I can’t wait to read your stories, Jan. I know they will be delicious. 🙂 As for me, I think the story comes first, though the story is alive with characters. 🙂

  • Annika Perry says:

    Jan, an interesting post and I would say I’m the same as you! Somehow the main character/s are intrinsically linked to the story. After that other characters are added and the story adjusted! I’m taken with your writing class and conversation about feelings – a very good point! Without thinking about it we put these at the core of our writings! Love, hate, jealousy, sadness, joy, fear … they are pivotal! Reading your post has made me want to just write and write! Inspiring post. Wishing you a lovely Sunday! Happy Writing! 😀🌺

    • rijanjks says:

      Oh yay!! I’m clapping my hands, Annika! I’m thrilled that the post inspired you to write and write! 🙂 Happy Sunday to you as well and YES, Happy Writing! Hugs!

  • I love this post which caused me to think about how I come up with story ideas. It is often an event first and then build characters around it.

  • Mine are a combo in the end but usually start with the story.

  • Mae Clair says:

    For me it’s almost always the characters. And with them come emotions. I like how you zeroed in on that in your post because emotions are what drive my characters. Every once in a great while I might get a plot idea without characters but that’s a rarity. Great post, Jan!

    • rijanjks says:

      I love that, Mae! I have enjoyed all of your characters and their emotions in the stories I’ve read. You do a great job! Thanks so much for weighing in. This has been an interesting discussion! Happy Sunday!

  • It varies for me too, Jan. I might get the spark of an idea, but the characters seem to jump right in and then the two weave together into the full concept. All fun!

  • Mine never seem to do the same thing twice. I find it easier when the character shows up first. I also get a lot of vignettes. Meaning a scene takes place with nameless and faceless characters. It isn’t a story, or even a plot. Then I find characters and dwell on it for a while. Sometimes it can expand into a story.

  • Staci Troilo says:

    I’m pretty much a concept person. I get an idea, but then the characters immediately follow, even before the plot is fleshed out. I think it’s because, for me, characters and plot are so closely intertwined. I can’t develop one without the other. But I seldom, if ever, start with a character first.

  • rijanjks says:

    Well-said, Staci. Indeed it takes both the characters and the story idea to make a whole picture! Interesting comment. Thanks!

I'd love to hear your thoughts!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.